why did joker kill randall

But this only serves to bring out the blandness and correctness of Murray Franklin, who as a consummate showman, also pulls off terrible one-liners. Why else do you think Randall gave Arthur a gun, snitched on him to his boss, and then asked what he had said to the cops. What positional accuracy (ie, arc seconds) is necessary to view Saturn, Uranus, beyond? Besides acting a bit strange, people tend to pick on Arthur Fleck because of his laugh. I feel as though Randall played some role in abusing Arthur as an adult. Thomas' actor even stated in interviews he played the character as if he was Arthur's father. So he made a "comedy" bit out of it instead. Why can't the police find Arthur after the subway shooting? Joker 's ending leaves the truth of the DC villain's origin almost as mysterious as before it began. His "girlfriend": He most likely did not kill her and just left the apartment. Nicotine is also an appetite suppressant, so there could be another reason why he smokes so much adding to his frail physique. and our Why didn't Murray have Arthur frisked for weapons near the end? Edit, He was just doing his job. Arthur Flecks crimes begin to catch up on him and two GCPD officers try to apprehend him during an action-packed chase scene. But fans have commented that they think he was always locked up and the entire film takes place in his head. The first scene we see Randall, as he hands Arthur a gun, Randall has an evil smile on his face while suggesting Arthur pays him back sometime, followed up with you know youre my boy. which triggers Arthurs laugh. 's required for entrance to all business offices, etc. Did people really laugh during Arthur's stand-up performance, or was it just his imagination? Arthur wouldn't have so many problems and sloppy miserable fantasies if it was all entirely imagined. Unlike regular superhero movies, (Shazam, Suicide Squad or any other Marvel movie), there is no one transformative moment in Arthur's story that made him the Joker. All rights reserved. Edit, Maybe. Did she have this procedure before the abuse took place and could this explain how the abuse could happen without her stopping it? Did nurses give them to him? Only in the last scene Arthur will spare him because he never was mean towards Arthur.Based on that logic, the last encounter of the trio gave Gary and Randall what they deserveSo Randall lied that Arthur got it from someone else and that Arthur even tried to buy one from Randall. Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. But exactly how many Batman movies did Brett Cullen appear in? He would have needed to set this bag down in order to retrieve two additional rounds and insert them in the weapon. The 3 guys in the subway attacked Arthur first. Because if he was, that scene must be in his head. It is further evidence he is likely to be on the spectrum. Edit, It was a Pre-Model 36 version of the Smith & Wesson Chief's .38 Special, it was mistakenly misidentified as a Colt Detective Special. When he goes down the stairs, it is an effortless journey of liberation as he metamorphosised into the full-dressed Joker for the first time and he danced down the stairs. Edit, There are nine confirmed deaths in the film, six of them killed by Arthur.The three Wall Street businessmen: shot to death, on the subwayRandall: stabbed in head with scissorsPenny Fleck: smothered with a pillow in the hospitalMurray Franklin: shot in the head at point blank range. | Box office takings are suggesting the critics are wrong. Joker is a movie that has taken both the box office and social media by storm, with the disturbing story of Arthur Fleck garnering mixed viewpoints among fans. Possibly the crowning moment is when he gets his first stand-up gig. It is currently unknown why she let this happen, but it's presumed she was abused by him as well, causing her mental problems. There's also the likelihood of (physical) trauma-induced amnesia or he simply repressed the memory. For example when he implied that Arthur laughed in his stand up comedy performance because he thought laughing so much would force the viewers to laugh too (suggesting that he was bad at jokes so he chose this as an alternate way to entertain people instead)Also, Murray's face expressions clearly explained that he was taunting Arthur through every word that he spoke, and that he was not being amused by any of his jokes. And he was flawless, composed and methodical. One thing I didn't quite understand in Joker was why Randall betrayed Arthur so quickly when the gun was found. Are there really 3 Jokers? Joker doesnt flinch as he drives a pair of scissors into his former boss eye and proceeds to repeatedly slam his head again a wall before he bleeds out. This scene can hit home to anyone who's ever done stand-up comedy and/or got stage fright. The point of this is to show the self-serving nature of the world around Arthur, and how willing people are to throw others under the bus.The point is that Randall wasn't as good of a friend as we thought he was. He lets fellow clown Gary (Leigh Gill) escape his apartment after Arthur stabs Randall in the eye and bashes his brains in. Like much else in this movie, whether this is *THE* Joker's origin story or just *A* Joker's origin story is left to the audience to guess. Edit, Passive people dont always stand up for their rights. When Arthur gets assaulted by a group of teenagers, Randall offers him a gun to defend himself, but when Arthur gets fired for possessing the weapon, Randall gives no help to him and demonstrates his true colors and gets killed by the newly turn nihilistic criminal Joker. Share. Failed comedian turned anarchist murderer, mob boss using the insanity plea, a pure force of chaos and evil- Gotham's dark side personified. (B) A competent defense lawyer (assuming Arthur could get one) could likely get the first two killings ruled justifiable homicides, but the third man he killed was retreating; pursuing him and finishing him off with malice aforethought as Arthur did is murder in the first degree according to the laws of every state in the USA. Arthur gets away with it, too, with it presumed that doctors believed she died as a result of her stroke rather than anything much more sinister. When Arthur's boss fired him over the gun, how come Arthur didn't mention Randall giving the gun to him because he was told to have it for self-defense? All three men make it onto a subway carriage but Arthur accidentally starts a melee. What Randall didn't think would happen, however, was that Joker would bring the gun into a children's hospital. But in reality, he is painfully inept and even repulsive. The police then find themselves unable to escape as clowns from all directions start grabbing them and beating them to a pulp. Where does Arthur get the bullets for his revolver? Instead of going into the cinema wanting to catch a movie about a comic book villain, audiences can watch it as a movie about a man broken by his mental illness. Or as **fanlore.org** calls it [Watsonian, not a Doylist point of view](http://fanlore.org/wiki/Watsonian_vs._Doylist). Joker 2019 movie scene HDFILM DESCRIPTION:Forever alone in a crowd, failed comedian Arthur Fleck seeks connection as he walks the streets of Gotham City. Arthur was making up at the dresser when he heard someone at the door, and he instinctively took with him a pair of scissors. Initially, all signs point to Joaquin Phoenixs character offing himself on live television to make a grand statement about mental illness and society, with Arthur even putting a gun to his head by a way of practice. "Comedy is subjective," says. The point is that he threw Arthur under the bus even when he didn't need to. Edit, One of the mind-bending twists is that whole sections of the movie are manifestations of Arthur delusions - such as his entire relationship with his next-door neighbor Sophie. Overall, Thomas' character is portrayed as a corrupt scumbag, so it is plausible he forged papers to save face. He instead ruthlessly murders the talk show host on live television and proceeds to address the citizens of Gotham, whipping them into a rebellious frenzy as a direct result. Edit, Randall gave the gun to Arthur for money (which he intended to demand from him later). When Arthur and Murray first meet each other, you can see that Murray is very respectful . Immediately following is a scene where a group of hoodlums steal his sign when he's doing promotional work as a clown. He lifts Bruces mouth into a twisted smile in a similar way he does when putting his clown make-up on in his dressing room at the start of the movie. Gary the midget was let go after witnessing Randall's murder. What does "up to" mean in "is first up to launch"? Edit, There is none. Well first, you answered your own question as Arthur saw Gary as his only real friend. Also, Todd did not want him in the film, because he wrote the script with Joaquin in mind. Mentioning the comedy, so a play, might also imply a sort of detachment now that he understands that it was all a lie from the beginning and she's not even his real mother (if that's what he believes). Patients may find themselves crying uncontrollably at something that is only moderately sad, being unable to stop themselves for several minutes. This puts Arthur's birth year in 1948 or 1949, meaning that he was 32-33 years old during the events of the film. He always got in trouble even when he didn't do anything wrong like when he got fired or when his boss thought he stole the sign so he started doing things intentionally to get in trouble and escalate events since either way he was always punished. Categories Also, cigarettes were cheap, and probably viewed by the staff as a type of pacifier.It would have been fairly easy for Arthur to get smokes. In order to discover whether or not this is true, he takes a trip to Wayne Manor and meets Bruce Wayne for the first time on the other side of a well-polished metallic gate. While not murdering is a positive, strangling the guy for doing his job is just plain wrong. Edit, There is every indication that the whole thing was in Arthur's head. Also, Murray seems to understand that Arthur isn't actually insane, It's clear that Arthur is trying to justify his crimes, and as far as Murray can tell, Arthur is pretending to be the subway murderer to gain attention. It's all in his head. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Who plays Batman, the other side of the coin, and why isn't he credited? Another one of his "jokes" (visions/episodes/whathaveyou) was more than likely the killing of the therapist, hence the whacky running back and forth through the hallways with the single bodyguard. The fridge can be seen as a womb of sorts, with Arthur climbing inside taking the fetal position and emerging anew as Joker. When he made fun of Arthur, he didn't know Arthur had a mental illness which caused him to laugh so much. 1981 is when the movie takes place, but did Joker become to become Joker in the 80's in the setting of other Batman movies? Just like no one thought his comedy bits were funny but him. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Edit, Viewers have to consider that the lie goes deeper than just the father's identity, if that is a lie at all. At the time, it would not have been unusual to allow Arthur to enter without frisking. Many think that the clerk in Arkham Asylum was fairly nice to Arthur, in searching for his mother's records. Leaving out "the" introduces a necessary ambiguity; after all, a key part of most versions of the Joker is that no one, not even he, truly know knows who he is or where he comes from. Arthur Fleck, later known as the Joker, is the titular main protagonist of the 2019 DC Black psychological comic book thriller-film of the same name and will return in its upcoming 2024 sequel Joker: Folie Deux. A film about the past of the Joker we see in The Dark Knight (often theorised to have been a veteran, based on some of his actions) would even be great. It might have been a bizarre passing scene to many moviegoers, almost somewhat funny, but that part about Arthur removing the contents of his fridge and hiding inside is poignant. That whole scene had me on edge for some reason and it was beautifully shot. The Pattinson Batman is more akin to the typical comic book formula. Todd makes it clear she wasn't killed. [CDATA[ Edit, If Arthur didn't drink alcohol, they probably wouldn't have brought him wine as a present. In a chat with /Film . RELATED:Every Record Joker Has Already Broken. Why did Arthur shut himself in the refrigerator? How to combine several legends in one frame? The events showing Arthur firing 8 rounds, none of which missed, could not have happened for two main reasons. It just seemed strange that he would not only completely turn on Arthur after the hospital fiasco (rather than coordinate with him to create a bullshit story) and then flat-out go to his apartment weeks later to try and intimidate him into silence. He's not hiding; he's just hanging out in normal place of residence. When she asks what's so funny, he hands her a card explaining he has a condition. Cookie Notice Murray became the "joke" and that joke was death. As for Beetz's character, Sher says it was the film's intention not to have the character die by Arthur's hands. "For instance, his relationship to Sophie is a fantasy to him. Edit, No one really knows. When Arthur murders his mother in the hospital, the heart monitor that she is connected to does not alarm as her heart rate skyrockets, then starts to fail. Edit, No. Edit, Bruce Wayne is only a child in this movie and doesn't really play a high-impact part, although Bruce's dad is a big part of the film. This would validate the murder a bit, at least in his mind. Why are they (the three men from the subway) called the Wall Street Three when Gotham is an entirely separate city from New York? A complete opposite of the Arthur who needed meds to cope. When Arthur gets assaulted by a group of teenagers, Randall offers him a gun to defend himself, but when Arthur gets fired for possessing the weapon, Randall gives no help to him and demonstrates his true colors and gets killed by the newly turn nihilistic criminal Joker. Are those cigarettes real? Please don't kill him." If youve ever wanted to shoot your shot at being an influencer, nows your chance. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. But it is also possible that Thomas Wayne fathered him with his Penny Fleck, but later denied it and had fake adoption papers put into her commitment papers. It's left ambiguous in the end. Has Penny always been delusional or did she get her mental illness because of all the sadness in her life? 3) His foot hurts from when he was kicking a trash bin earlier in the film He is obviously very thin, his skeletal appearance is similar to that of a person suffering from anorexia. | Edit, Two possibilities: Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Maybe he was he still hung up about the gun. Laughing at death is certainly a Joker trait and means that, by the end of the movie, his character is where we expect him to be - both literally and physically. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. I feel kind of silly for saying this but that was an adorable moment in the film. The splattering of blood on Joker's white face paint was a very nice touch. To paraphrase: While audiences (non-critics) are loving the movie for what it depicts and how powerfully it does so, the media narratives have accused Joker of promoting gratuitous violence and serving as a call to arms for incels. Arthur all. PBA occurs secondary to a neurologic disorder or brain injury. VASPKIT and SeeK-path recommend different paths. Batman Wiki is a FANDOM Comics Community. This is in contrast to what critics and the American mainstream media are saying about the movie, which has been vilified by some quarters. In other words: Who Arthur imagines himself to be, and how he eventually acts, finally comes together. But within this call for help is also the speaking of truth. At the very end, Arthur supposedly kills the black doctor off-screen in the hospital. But as Murray is horrified to the revelation that Arthur killed the three Wall Street guys earlier in the movie, Joker has a change of heart. Or was this scene a fantasy, a retelling of what supposedly happened or a wish of what happened? Does this mean Arthur was prepared to kill anyone who walked through his door? This movie took place a long time ago and people were not as knowledgeable on conditions like Arthur's Just when he thinks he's caught up to them in an alleyway, they smash the sign over his face. Cloud hosting by Vodien. Should we treat this as such a choice? Did Thomas Wayne really have an affair with Penny? To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. I tensed up. But by the time Arthur gets on the show with Murray Franklin, he becomes a natural showman. Edit, Enough to make a sequel, or at least the money. He appeared to be trying to show Arthur the error of his ways during the conversation6.) More broadly speaking, Wayne's publicly stating on television that Gotham's underclass were "clowns" like that guy who murdered those three brokers from his company (referring to Fleck, though Wayne didn't know he was that guy at the time) certainly made him seem "rude" in their eyes as well. When Arthur is told by his mother, Penny Fleck, that hes related to Thomas Wayne, he takes her words at face value. One such moment is when Randall (the same Randall who gave him a gun and lied about it) visits his apartment with dwarf David by his side. | Joaquin played the role perfectly. If this incident (or something like it) did in fact happen, Thomas was most likely "flying off the handle" at Arthur for having put his fingers in his son Bruce's mouth; a rather creepy violation of the child's personal space that would seriously upset any decent parent or guardian, though not necessarily to the point of provoking such a violent reaction. 3) The name joker ends up being a title that Gotham's craziest, most dangerous and influential criminal takes over; this would allow for a "Jokerverse" where each style of Joker gets his day. Arthur tries running after them (calling for help and getting no response), which isn't easy given he's wearing oversized shoes. While to assume that everyone in it is either corrupt or lazy and shiftless is perhaps getting into Arthur's nihilistic viewpoint a bit too closely. Is Thomas Wayne considered an antagonist in this film? Whenever Arthur trudges up the stairs, which are plenty, it is a physical representation of his struggle in life as Arthur. Arthur is in Arkham. Edit, Viewers have offered two opinions1.) Answer (1 of 3): No. Why does Arthur kill his mother? Sometimes, the episodes may switch between emotional states, resulting in the patient crying uncontrollably before dissolving into fits of laughter. He wasn't even going to kill Murray until he kept provoking him. Randall is shown to be so concerned for Arthur's well-being after he gets beaten that he gives him the firearm to defend himself. Edit, Yes, it is possible, but considering how things develop and are revealed through the film this all seems highly unlikely and if it were true, then it would give the viewing audience no clue. Was Thomas Wayne meant to be a character who is "rude" like Arthur Fleck says? But all this ends up being in his head and Arthur breaks into Sophies apartment. Belmont Lay Everything between that was in his head. (D) Arthur being mentally ill and therefore a rather unreliable witness, he'd have a difficult time getting anyone to believe his testimony, especially when facing in court the (probably) more affluent and better educated friends and families and employers of the three men he killed. After his stand-up act, Arthur and Sophie's little romance was the only heartwarming part of Joker - but none of it was real. Edit, It's implied that Arthur killed the psychologist who was talking to him and asked him about what he was laughing about at the end of the movie.I did think that was probably the case but I also thought it was odd she was alone with him in the room considering what he had supposedly done.Note that he had handcuffs on as he spoke with her, and continued to have them when he was walking down the hall, dancing, and being chased by staff. It doesn't tie into any other comic book or movie continuity, but is still based on the DC character. Plus he did bring the gun in the children hospital (the same way he started dancing with it and shot the wall in his apartment) not something he did for no purpose he did want to carry the gun for self-defense even though it's a firing offense if he is caught with it. He clearly was mocking him. Interpreting non-statistically significant results: Do we have "no evidence" or "insufficient evidence" to reject the null. No copyright infringement Thats definitely odd and its no wonder Alfred Pennyworth tries to defend Bruce Arthur expects Alfred Pennyworth, being British and all, to invite him in for a nice cup of tea where he can talk about both Thomas Wayne and his relationship with his mother. The scene at the very end, with Arthur locked up talking to the doctor/social worker - is it meant to be later, after he's been captured again, or is it a flashback to when he was hospitalised before, as was referenced earlier in the movie? Edit, Without corroborating evidence, such as eye witness reports, security camera footage or the murder weapon itself, it would be difficult to convince a judge to issue a warrant. Was Gary actually the only person who was nice to Arthur throughout the whole movie? and our The entire ending, after all, plays like a deranged and alienated man's ultimate fantasy - he publicly gets even with everyone who ever humiliated him, murders a famous celebrity live on national television, and not only does everyone love him, he inspires a mass movement that seems to worship him. The Joker in comic book canon has been quoted as saying that if he had to have a past, he would prefer that it be multiple choice. RELATED:Joaquin Phoenix's Joker: 5 Times He Was Sympathetic (And 5 Times He Went Too Far). It is difficult to argue that the casting of these characters in all these scenes was a coincidence, or that it is a shot at diversity representation. (A) The police are not tasked with sorting out what's murder and what's self-defense; that's for courts to decide. RELATED: Joker's Backlash Ended Up Being A Marketing Trick. Arthur took a lot of anti depressant medication, and didn't seem to accept being offered alcohol, like when Randall and Gary came to his apartment with what appeared to be a wine bottle so did Arthur have to avoid alcohol while taking his anti depressant medication? Plot a one variable function with different values for parameters? At the beginning of the film they're both shown to be good enough friends that they joke together. During his appearance on Franklin's show, Joker tells cruel, unfunny jokes that elicit groans from the audience and a verbal scolding from one of his fellow guests. Then he claimed Arthur wanted to buy it. Joker is not a complete psychopath, as he also displays acts of kindness. The scene has led to debates over whether or not the entire film is Arthur's fantasy. But wasnt Arthur afraid at all that Gary would go to the police and tell him that Arthur killed Randall? 1) He is likely still sore from the jumping he took at the beginning of the movie. When Arthur suffocated his mother in hospital and her pulse flatlined, there was no one around to intervene (assuming this murder did take place and wasn't just in Arthur's head). Arthur killed his mother in a pre-meditated way as he snuffed her out with a pillow in the hospital. (big clown coworker that gives him a gun) 4 7 comments Add a Comment 3 yr. ago Randal was the one who told his boss that he had a gun and that it was Arthur who wanted to buy one off him Owen_301 3 yr. ago Pretty sure his boss found out when it fell out at the hospital kidcuisine27 3 yr. ago [deleted] Edit, You can see that Murray himself does little goofy dances all the time during his show and Arthur sorta seems to have taken that trait from him. Privacy Policy. Even then Randall takes advantage of the good nature of Arthur by talking him into taking the gun.When things go awry, Randall quickly (and successfully) tries to push the blame on Arthur, which is when Arthur realizes the true colors of Randall.Then later, when the walls are closing in on the gun, Randall makes contact with Arthur again, to ensure that "their stories will align". If it was reality there is no way ( after killing all those people ) they would have allowed Arthur to be in the interview room at Arkham just sitting opposite his counsellor. He could have gotten them through a visitor of another patient, or perhaps even through a cigarette vending machine at the hospital. Arthur figured out that Randall set him down this path into madness and wronged him which is why he murders him out of vengeance. To his horror, his conditions rears its head during a trip on the subway, where three Wall Street guys round on him and attempt to beat him to a pulp. He . I get that Gary was the only one who was ever nice to Arthur, so he spared him. "You've always been nice to me." Arthur is killing people who've wronged him in a certain way, and Sophie never wronged him." Inspections have been carried out at the ferry terminal by Indonesian authorities. Why did Arthur do the suicidal self-shooting gesture to Sophie in her apartment? Through the information he saw on the medical record - and he kills her after seeing that record - it turns out that she had let him be abused and beaten up since a tender age, which would probably be the cause of his mental and physical issues. Also in those records are some newspaper clippings that reveal Arthur was three years old when the authorities learned that his mother's boyfriend abused them. Why exactly was Arthur locked up in the hospital BEFORE the events of the film? What was real was that after Arthur murdered his mother, he broke into Sophie's apartment, frightening her. Edit, Todd Phillips suggests that this isn't necessarily supposed to be the actual Batman-fighting Joker. By Alex Leadbeater. He showed up to make sure Arthur wouldn't incriminate him in the subway murders. This also reinforces the idea that he's a product of his environment - cold and dark.4.) RELATED:Joaquin Phoenix Wanted Joker To Have End-Credits Footage. It's not established Penny's not Arthur/Joker's biological mother and that she ever lied about her relationship with Thomas Wayne. It appears he is laughing about the death of Thomas Wayne, we see a flash of that scene again for a reason. isle of dogs budget and box office, who does karen marry in one tree hill,

Undone In Sorrow'' Banjo Tab, Why Did David Lyons Leave Sea Patrol, Articles W