iframe authentication problem

Hi, I have a PowerApp embedded in a SharePoint page using an iframe in an embed web part. If I am authenticated in the parent domain, hydra would know and I could skip the verification and consent in the iframes domain. Maybe I use wrong. Some WordPress security setting and plugin perhaps? i would just need an email address or mobile number to send it to. I prefer one service that handles account management. IFRAME Problem - Basic Authentication Emre CELEBI Nov 04, 2018 Hello, I have added IFRAME into one of my confluence page. This works except when the device is an affected device. Embed and authenticate ASP.NET MVC Application inside an IFRAME Suggested Answer One way I can think of is to pass the user id to the Iframe context (have to enable cross site scripting), then get the user id from querystring and do the WCF impersonation. If so, can you try either removing that, or putting web.powerapps.com into your trusted sites and see if that fixes it? You might be having difficulty with same-site cookies issued across browsers especially as it relates to iFrames. one you also have administrative control over) in an iframe you should be okay? Anyway we could debate for a while; we will have to agree to disagree on this one. I checked the samesite attribute and every other configuration for cookies, as well as for iframes. Stripe automatically displays the authentication UI in a pop-up modal when calling confirmCardPayment and handleCardAction. Starting the authentication flowDepending on your application, you have probably implemented one of the following ways to start the authentication flow: 1. onClick function that will start the authentication flow and redirect a user to the authentication page 2. a middleware on the specific route that will start the authentication flow and redirect a user to the authentication page. Is there a starter template for Blazor WebAssembly that authenticates users and uses something other than Identity Server? Hi Uttam! Hope you read the comments….A lot of this information is outdated or inaccurate. http://xxx.xxx.xx.xx:8080/view/Nightly%20Builds%20/, http://xxx.xxx.xx.xx:8080/view/Nightly%20Builds%20/?auth=AUTH_TOKEN, AI applications open new security vulnerabilities, How chaos engineering preps developers for the ultimate game day (Ep. Site design / logo © 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. However, once you close Edge, relaunch, and load the page the sign-in loop is back. Needless to say, this would result in a highly rigid, ungainly system that would make editing a nightmare. The 'updateModule' and 'AddNewModule' options are missing from my…, Hi very sorry for the late reply, im not quite sure what you mean? This whole rant started because you saw an iframe and made the assumption that the technology was from 1997 which is not true. How to pass authentication details to application inside iframe? Thank you very much. Just make sure that the iframe is rendered in the DOM before redirecting a user. (\renewcommand doesn't work ), Integration cannot be replaced by discrete sum, Building A Function Using Constants From a List, A story where a child discovers the joy of walking to school. For tabs I suggest “Tabs & Sliders” from our sister web site JoomlaShack.com. I am checking on this for you; will let you know if I hear anything on a partial upgrade, but it is not one of our current offerings from our Sales/Marketing team. How does NASA have permission to test a nuclear engine? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions page for information on Community features, and tips to make the most of your time here. msdn.microsoft.com/./gg309629 (v=crm.6).aspx The current spate of ransomware attacks is proof of that. Reason #3. [EDIT] After looking a little deeper, it looks like the iFrame source URL is being built by com.liferay.portlet.iframe.action.ViewAction (as expected), and the problem exists in the "getUserName" method of this class. You can obviously handle any extra parameters this way. Keep up to date with current events and community announcements in the Power Apps community. You'll need to write code to persist the JWT and send the JWT bearer token to each secured Web API endpoints. In this article I will mostly focus on technical implementation and not the fact weather you should avoid iframe or not. Statements in differential geometry independent from ZFC. Embedding the PowerApp in a PowerBi dashboard instead of a SharePoint page. Create an iframe where you want to display authentication page and give it a unique name. Cheers, Content within the iframe doesn’t fit in and looks odd. This, let’s call it Map.JS, is dependent on an older version jQuery (this is the part where I don’t deem this best, because the jQuery version in question has a few know vulnerabilities, but let’s say for example, that we could use the latest jQuery version). All rights reserved. I have added IFRAME into one of my confluence page. It’s been a while since the last time you had the pleasure of having your application consumed from an Iframe. Now we need to add some JavaScript which will actually redirect a user. It confuses users, suddenly opening the iframe content in a new browser window. Also, question why x-frame-options went and implemented allow-from in more recent approaches effectively implementing SAMEORIGIN approach but with a whitelist.   You cannot paste images directly. I assume you have javascript function for handling the username and password or authToken validation function authTokenValidate (token) { api for validating the token and then redirection to http://xxx.xxx.xx.xx:8080/view/Nightly%20Builds%20/ } Why the heck would you add an iFrame from a possibly malicious website? If you are not happy with Identity Server's implementation then you can always roll your own, use the MSAL library or use a different authentication server and API. What was your ultimate solution here, did you go with the iframe for the payment screens? Navigation of the site in the iframe stops working. 1 affected device was Azure-AD joined, the other 1 device was Azure-AD registered. I have plenty of experience with .NET Identity and the old Membership Providers of the past too. I strongly advise you stay away from using the iframe tag. My question is direct to FitBit and I am asking them to make an exception for the specific URL mentioned above to allow iframe usage. 2018-04-18 03:40 AM. The recommended and officially supported integration for web applications has always been to redirect the user away from your application to the authorization page in the primary browser window or a pop-up. However, if I open another browser tab and go to app B, SSO works and it automatically authenticates. I was surprised that Microsoft (and apparently other OAuth applications) went down that path. Into the iFrame space I was asked to autenticate vs sway (note I'm ACTIVE on mySway in an other tab of my browser); then I've a pop up instance that -automatically- authenticate me. I will just work with Blazor Server for the time being. my first problem is i cant get the data page to stay logged in while its in an i frame. If forms authentication is used, then you should be able to POST the credentials, if you look at the code in the form to get the real names of the form variables. Join now to unlock these features and more. There is no shortage of information on this subject. If you've already registered, sign in. I will never create a serious application of any use that authenticates and authorizes anyone via a service that is not under my control. Hi @Paul Marangoni , I create default Blazor WebAssembly with Identity project but it does not have any iframe. (Learn more on OWASP.)   Your previous content has been restored. I will try reach out to the Edge team to see if they have any suggestions, but I believe it is part of their security model. True, but there is a ton of conflicting information on it, and Microsoft glosses over the Authentication/Authorization most of the time. The same if you use a different webpage from the parent site? I would never, ever use an iframe. Here's a list of common problems with MIP PDF files and troubleshooting steps to resolve the issues. Your responses indicate you do not have this situation. Complete this step even if you're positive it's the correct password. Did the developer write secure code? The Fitbit API launched publicly in 2011. The current spate of ransomware attacks is proof of that. Thank you so much for your support! After successful authentication, a user will be redirected to the redirect URL you provided when starting the authentication flow — usually a private route they tried to access in the first place. I found a 'dirty' workaround by creating a rudimentary API in PHP that handles the authentication for me. rev 2023.1.25.43191. I have no interest in OAuth. How to display authentication page inside of an iframe 2. Also checked everything is HTTPS -> HTTPS. Join the Kudos program to earn points and save your progress. It will be an intranet site with less than 300 users so that should be fine. You must be a registered user to add a comment. How to rename List of Tables? 3. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. We pre-announce backwards-incompatible changes for recommended and supported integration methods 30 or more days in advance. We are facing lot of issues when working with Angular and iframe.. Performing a "Repair" in the advanced options in Windows Settings for Edge (not the settings you can access from the browser). Only the application server can get to the database. Blazor like any SPA is downloaded and runs in the browser. Do this by accessing the Wi-Fi settings, and then open the gear/settings icon next to the network that is displaying the error, and choose Forget . I also share it with my co-workers. - With touch - Touch with two fingers for 1 to 2 seconds then release. We use Java, Rails, and JavaScript. You are making assumptions based on opinion and prior observations not facts. How can I register? Hi Alex, This kind of…. It would not give me the session ID from an iframe in Edge. Indeed, custom URL/domain is the only feature we really need from HA. We will cover two main objectives in this article: 1. And the kind of thinking that lies behind prohibition that you’re supporting has cost me money with no appreciable benefit. Qlik Sense extensions, mashups, integrations and APIs. Configure JWT bearer tokens in the startup. Not the answer you're looking for? Do you have sharepoint in your trusted sites (Internet explorer settings)? More info about Internet Explorer and Microsoft Edge. If you've worked with enough organizations you will realize that most (if not all) don't do things properly. To avoid this problem, we will crate another route /redirect which will render only a spinner and a generic message that the user is being redirect to the page. Yes, it looks that way. The chatbox is plugged-in in the parent webpage (like facebook messenger plugged-in) And yes, you can copy an app through the rest API. Because it is a trusted site?[/quote]. ‎07-03-2014 Auth0 includes the following HTTP headers to mitigate clickjacking attack. You don't have to worry about several applications that manage internal user accounts. Create pages that Google can crawl and associate with your site easily. Site design / logo © 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. just excuse the appearance its far from done. For example, publish facing applications cannot access a database directly, the apps must go through an application server. Google recommends refraining from creating iframes. This is a pretty good explanation on the security zones in internet explorer (even though it is rather old), https://www.itprotoday.com/security/guide-internet-explorer-security-zones. Hi, You could use anonymous login or configure a virtual proxy to use header authentication for this. Fitbit will always prioritize user security and I hope that you can understand our position. Unfortunately, you have not defined the client(s) or what you are securing. Qlik embedded via iframe authentication Options Not applicable 2016-08-23 09:30 AM Qlik embedded via iframe authentication Dear Experts, Our setup: Qlik sense separate server. We will not remove the X-Frame-Options header on this page for this reason. This is a bit longer of a post, but I wanted to give you some jumping-off points to explore different solutions. We are not considering implementing an option for third-party app developers to whitelist themselves, as an attacker could use this feature to whitelist their attack. Finally, below is also some information regarding CORS and I-Frame/Headers that might be useful/good background. I am asking Microsoft why they are using an iframe in their template. The POS machines are behind a f/w and we are facing page launch issues of the payment page for the 1st few attempts and after couple of times page refresh in the iframe the page loads and from there on there were no issues. rev 2023.1.25.43191. Create a new JS file and link it in the /redirect page. One of our customers implemented an iframe on their website. This is an infinite loop! This was very typical of the iframe tag. Show me how many new more modern sites use alert() v's some toastWindow implementation. We believe redirects and pop-up windows for authorization to be required for user security. When teaching online, how the teacher visualizes concepts? Loading embeded video or similar from trusted sites like YouTube and gMaps. It shouldn't be this convoluted. After building the app and applying the database migration for identity, I fired it up. The OAuth 2.0 spec explicitly says to not use iframes and to send the X-Frame-Options header set to deny or sameorigin: http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6749#section-10.13. Thanks, but I had already read that document. Refund for cancelled DB train but I don't have a German bank account. Please allow a few minutes for this process to complete. We recently learned that this had reverted at some point and re-enabled it. Did you ever get a response to this question? Obviously you won’t add an iFrame from a website that isn’t trusted. Practical (not theoretical) examples of where a 1 sided test would be valid? Or with config file (fusionauth.properties): Also, perhaps obviously, I wonder if there are any rules in place for your App B and App A that you might not have accounted for? 2. https://fusionauth.io/docs/v1/tech/reference/configuration/#options. These 2 applications are working on the same tomcat. A malicious user can hijack your users’ keystrokes. It actually happens in every browser i've tested in (Chrome, Edge and Firefox, and IE). Can I re-terminate this ISDN connector to an RJ45 connector? We currently have two apps in different domains, A and B. Is there something the PowerApps team or Edge team can do to fix this issue so the trusted sites workaround isn't necessary? This seems to be for websites. When a user is authenticated in A, and goes to the iframe page, it is required to authenticate again for B inside the iframe. A is a Wordpress website, and in one of its pages, there is an iframe with src to app B. 1 Answer Sorted by: 12 I think you need to handle the page. The problem is you created a mental picture of how you think security in Blazor WASM should work. We're working on providing some better error messaging in this case, but at this point in time, I'm not sure there is anything we can do to fix. IFRAME’s sandbox properties lets you prevent any parent child interactions; as it’s being served from another domain. If proxies and custom cookies sounds enticing, you could front FusionAuth Cloud with a CDN like Cloudflare. I’d like to add that all embed codes for Instragram, Facebook and Youtube fully rely on IFrames. I know how SPAs work (or rather, suck). Just, this does not work in an iframe. I have no interest in OAuth. Thanks a lot for yours responses. All rights reserved. Such as #access_token= for instance. The OAuth/OIDC protocol is a nice tool because authentication/authorization services are centralized and the protocol handles different client types. You might manage to rectify it now, only for you and your visitors to get problems with Google, usability, or security later. The other option is utilizing APIs when available, but it will require some coding knowledge, or pre-built plugins for whatever system you are using for your site. The Cloudflare option might be good, but I'm not sure which kind of cookie would I need to set for making it work. As you have raised user security is prioritized, I cant agree fully with your point, simply because you accept REST APIs via HTTP mode when getting user content rather than HTTPS mode. But if the server is in the same domain, it could easily use XMLHttpRequest. It has plenty of issues itself, and like everything else, will be replaced by yet another standard soon enough. In this case, would it be possible to do a "partial upgrade", meaning paying more just for this feature? This works! Apache tomcat 7 on a separate server, with the bonita portal (user/pw in a postgres db) and an angularjs web application. The specific device I am doing most my testing on is a Lenovo M710 running Windows 10 Pro. This has affected 2 devices of those 8 devices tested so far; in testing, the issue did not show user affinity. Both of those scenarios could be a source of your current issues as well. Most likely you are attempting to prevent clickJacking with this parameter; but this makes no sense when you want developers to integate fitbit authentication into a web app. When you click the "Sign in" button, it opens a popup, the popup closes, then the webpart displays a loading spinner for a few hundred milliseconds before displaying the "Sign In" message again. The authentication problem I am running into only occurs with the initial Authentication process where the App permissions dialog would be normally be presented, but within the apps.facebook.com iframe. As always, we welcome your feedback and suggestions. Our mission is to bring the invaluable knowledge and experiences of experts from all over the world to the novice. © 2022 Caspio, Inc. Sunnyvale, California. How can I access the contents of an iframe with JavaScript/jQuery? The question is, are you expecting step 2 to just work through SSO. are you staying on https for all iframes? Get answers to your question from experts in the community, Share a use case, discuss your favorite features, or get input from the community,